I’m delighted for the opportunity to share my good friend, Bob Yamtich’s perspective on Twice-exceptionality. I love what he has to say about his experiences and how to support 2e kids.
A few years ago, I left a self-help group of adults with Asperger’s Syndrome, offering gratitude for the group’s support over a span of years and reporting “I think it’s more that I’m gifted than Aspie.” I promptly received replies, “That sounds like black-and-white thinking; it could be both” and “You are always welcome back.”
I have since returned and remain grateful to their support. It’s always a blessing to find one’s tribe, even if that tribe has a lot of different names and meeting places.
When Jade invited me to write a guest blog about Type 5: The Twice-Exceptional (2e) child, I immediately said “yes!” and started taking an honest look at any insights I could offer to address this. I looked (again) at the 1988 article profiling the six types of gifted, back when they were calling 2e “the double labeled.”
As I mentioned, two of my main exceptionalities are giftedness and Asperger’s traits, so my understanding of 2e comes from both self-exploration as well as my work as a therapist and coach with gifted/2e families.
For the past several posts, Jade has been working with you to identify and understand the six types of gifted child. And if you answered mostly E’s in her quiz, you may have a Type 5 gifted child. The Twice-Exceptional child refers to intellectually gifted children who have some other form of possibly diagnosable condition, often viewed as a disability (though I certainly don’t see it that way).
By now, I imagine most all of those reading Jade’s blog know that asynchronous development and the overexcitabilities of giftedness can lead to precocious access to perception, understanding, and wisdom. However, I would like to describe a more humble perspective: it took me years of therapy to cry (although I tried to speed up the process by bringing an onion, chopping board and knife) and say “Some things are hard for me.”
No matter how gifted they are, some things are hard for your kids.
Whether it is a difference in social thinking like Asperger’s, a difference like dyslexia, anxiety or ADHD traits, or even existential depression, any of these aspects of one’s experience can have challenging implications.
The combination of precocious understanding and lagging skills is complicated and confusing for your child. Their cognitive abilities and a longing for self-acceptance can make them impenetrable to feedback, out of fear of hearing criticism.
If your child struggles to understand their own complexity, how can you support them?
Talk openly with them about their exceptionalities. Ask how their mind works, and if it is fun to be them. Provide opportunities for self-exploration and understanding. Listen for any metaphors that give texture to their experience. And listen carefully.
Each person can have a custom-tailored self-understanding to better prepare them to have shared understanding with others. They say that in both love and therapy, you can only go as far as you have gone yourself. Go there with them.
I recommend preventive counseling for gifted and 2e kiddos, because complicated minds can build complicated traps.
And explore any other family members or historical figures who may share some of their exceptionalities. (Personally, I love knowing that my grandfather was a machinist with a keen attention to detail).
If possible, find mentors to engage them in their areas of strength while gently encouraging skill development where they lag behind.
A gifted/2e person does well to go far in their self-understanding, so that they can have more internal space to understand others and the world around them.
That understanding can lead to more acceptance, of self and others, and help increase ease and fun.
Have you talked with your kid openly about their giftedness and twice-exceptionality? How did it go? I’d love to hear all about it in the comments below!
And next, Jade will return to discuss Type 6: The Autonomous Learner in more detail. I know I personally can’t wait to read it!
————————————————-
Bob Yamtich, a Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist in California, has a private practice providing therapeutic communication coaching to gifted and 2e families. He and his wife are expecting their first child and are curious to see how many exceptionalities their new babe will have. You can learn more about his work at www.bobyamtich.com.
*This blog post is based on the article, Profiles of the Gifted and Talented (Betts, George, and Maureen Neihart. Profiles of the gifted and talented. Gifted Child Quarterly, National Association for Gifted Children (NAGC), 1988. Web. 2013. <http://www.davidsongifted.org/db/Articles_id_10114.aspx>.).
“Complicated minds can build complicated traps.” Oh my, yes. And talking openly with your kids. Wise words, Bob. Thanks to you and Jade for all that you do for gifted children and their parents.
Thanks, Paula! It’s such an honor to write a guest post for Jade; I have long admired her intuitive, nuanced, and empathetic work with kids and families.
Thank you, Paula and thank you Bob. It feels great to be able to count you two as friends.
I really enjoy reading your perspective, it certainly gives me new insights into my 2E son and how I can support him through his journey. My son is 7 and he’s aware that he’s different however I’ve never used the words 2E or gifted yet. I have explained to him what I call learning strengths and learning challenges to help explain why he’s ahead in some areas and why he struggles with others.
Wendi, I think it is great how you openly discuss your son’s strengths and challenges! One of the main benefits of gifted theory is to have a starting place to look for resources (including community) and understanding of self and others.
Gifted identification catalyzes a person’s self-understanding and their ability to gather resources to meet needs. No pressure on using specific terms, as long as the dialogue continues.
“Ask them how their mind works and if it is fun to be them.” I love this sentence. I know that sometimes as a parent, I assume a lot based on my own experiences. When I stop to ask questions like this, I learn so much more about my child. I appreciate your insightful words.
My husband is gifted with aspie traits as well. I’m off to your blog archives to help me learn more about him, too. 🙂
Yay! I like how empowering it is for a kid to define themselves. Depending on their response, I might extend the conversation by asking “Is there a flavor of _____?”
And, thanks for checking out my blog archives! I hope something there contributes to you and your family.
This is wonderful, thankyou. It has given me a few starting points to talk with my son that I hadn’t previously thought about.
Cool! I’m glad to contribute to conversations within families.
Your mention of trying to cry and bringing an onion. My mother always thought something was always worried about my father because he never cried. Even when his own mother passed away he never even shed a tear (though he loved his mother more than words could express). I never knew this was a trait in gifted with aspie traits until I started delving into this.
Thanks for your comment. I am glad you were able to be aware of his love for his mother, even if he did not demonstrate care (or mourning) in typical ways. We certainly all have different ways to mourn, different ways to cope with loss of a loved one or even the temporary status of a need not being met to our satisfaction. For me, sometimes I inventory and note happenings with great care, tracking and considering what would best serve the moment. Also, sometimes it takes me a long time to connect with my feelings, and I begin with an awareness that I need more time to process.
This makes so much sense! Your response makes things that much more clear and understandable.
Hi Jade,
Maureen Neihart and I have been developing the Profiles of the Gifted (The Six Types of Gifted Children) since 1985. I believe your readers would enjoy more information on the Six Types from the authors of this approach. Also, they can research online the profiles matrix from 2010.
http://www.ingeniosus.net/archives/dr-george-betts-and-dr-maureen-neihart-share-revised-profiles-of-gifted
Hello Dr. Betts,
I think you’re correct, they will enjoy more information from the authors. Are you planning to continue your research? Thank you and Dr. Neihart for conducting the research, and writing this powerful paper that is bringing so much clarity to gifted families all over the world. We are grateful to you both.
Best,
Jade Rivera
Jade, this is really helpful – I especially like how you have expanded on the matrix into a format that makes easy reading. Understanding all of these traits can be overwhelming for parents new to giftedness; having a reader-friendly format provides context for those who may need it. 🙂
Thank you, Corin! Helping gifted families is the thing I love to do most in this world. 🙂
I truly enjoy working with students who are gifted, but have some traits that make school and life difficult for them. As this article reiterates, these gifted students need to know what makes them unique. I tell them that this uniqueness is the very thing that may make them perfect for some great lifework. It is a challenge to create lessons for them that stretch them in the areas in which they need to grow.
How does the information in this article/video influence my approach to students?
My approach to students is that they are all special in their own way and I respect who they are and what they add to the classroom.
What insight has been gained that is worth sharing with my educational community? (administrators,
teachers, coaches, parents, etc.)Everyone has a purpose and that purpose is connected with everyone in the world.
What action do I need to take? I think the more knowledge we can gain about gifted children the better our world can be because they are included in it.
These profile makes me think on how labels can cause so much damage. Being labeled with a learning disability could hinder social and academic development.
This article has allowed me to reflect on myself as I reflect on another peers comments about their mom. I cannot even discuss now. At any rate, we have many students in our classrooms that have many exceptionalities. Different facets of learning, and learning disabilities. As a teacher, we must always be empathic, and understanding even when we may not understand the whole learning dynamics of our learners.